The true Catholic position
Thank you, Brother Peter, for exposing the contradictions, errors, and mistranslations from Magisterial documents involved in Pinesap’s heretical and indefensible position that non-Catholics can be saved. Debates of this kind really show the nonsensical and fragile basis of the baptism of desire position, because once its falsehoods are dismantled one by one, as is done here, the true Catholic position is the only one that makes sense and is consistent and holds up to scrutiny. In order to defend his position Pinesap had to fall back on vague and condemned arguments of heretics such as "nuances" or pretending to agree with the true position in some areas but then immediately contradicting it… the heretic Pinesap is exposed by his own admissions and floundering around to try to reconcile the many contradictions and flaws in his case.
God bless you
Bro. Peter asked a great question to ask people like Pinesap: Can someone be a Catholic/have the Catholic faith while practicing a false religion such as Judaism or Islam? Pinesap has to say yes if he wants to keep his position consistent. But he doesn't want to just say "yes" clearly and without obfuscation because it's so obviously absurd. This is what BOD leads to - believing someone can be Catholic "in their heart" while simultaneously sitting in a synagogue praying for the coming of the "messiah" and expressing belief in the Talmud which teaches that Jesus Christ is a false prophet boiling in excrement in sheol. It's absolutely absurd and Pinesap needs many prayers so he can convert to Catholicism.
"Invincible ignorance" heretics don't believe in Divine Providence.
At the end pinesap knew he was caught in a contradiction. Still he wouldn't accept the infallible dogmatic truth, that before Anyone dies they Must Become Catholic!
Sign up for our free e-mail list to see future vaticancatholic.com videos and articles.