Taylor Marshall obstinately adheres to false positions and has for years

Comment

Taylor Marshall’s Errors, Contradictions, And Deception

Excellent -- heresy is fatal.

Joseph Sellars

Destructive

No, what he does is not good enough. It is, in fact, destructive and deceptive, as the video shows. First, he CONSTANTLY tells people to share his videos and promote him. He wants people to listen to him, promote him, and read his material. He also comments on most breaking news stories with regard to the Counter Church. That only increases his culpability. He has an obligation to tell the full truth anyway. But when he’s so aggressive in promoting himself as a teacher he thinks people should be promoting, he becomes even more responsible. Yet, he doesn’t get things correct. If he’s incapable of telling the full truth or understanding the situation, he shouldn’t comment on these matters. He should leave it to people who actually have the faith, can see what’s happening, and are looking to please God rather than men. He obstinately adheres to false positions and has for years. Spreading partial truth on these matters won’t cut it. These matters concern heresy, apostasy, mortal sin, idolatry, eternal hellfire, etc.

Moreover, his history has shown that he’s not a person who serves God. He only started to criticize Antipope Francis in 2016, after it became fashionable in false traditionalist circles to do so. He ignored Francis’ horrible apostasy for the first three years, as well as ignoring the apostasy of Benedict XVI for years. When it looked like Francis might sack the FSSP, he became much more aggressive in his rhetoric. He began to call him a heretic and ‘Bergoglio’ (even though Francis had taught many heresies before that time). But when the news came out that Francis would let the FSSP remain as they are for a time, Marshall started calling him ‘Pope Francis’ again. That’s a heretical reed in the wind, a person who is ripe for use by Satan. He is used by the Devil as a counterfeit answer to the current crisis. He steers large numbers of false traditionalists away from the true conclusions. As the video covers, they listen to him, thinking that they are informed, but they aren't.

Also, the fact that you call Francis ‘Pope’, in the face of the facts available to you, shows that you have no faith and no understanding of the situation. You reject the facts that are available to you. You need to stop resisting the truth and become a true Catholic.