Our Challenge to Debate R.I. – Refused in Cowardly Fashion

NOTE: In recent months, this individual R.I. has actually denounced canonized Catholics saints as heretics.  Specifically, he has denounced St. Alphonsus and St. Thomas Aquinas as heretics.  This proves what I have said about him, that he is a non-Catholic heretic who has literally founded his own sect.  Some people couldn’t see it then, but perhaps they see it now.  By denouncing as heretics canonized saints, he actually has put himself on the level of the Protestant reformers.  He is now in the category of Protestant revolutionaries Martin Luther, John Calvin and other heretics (such as Joseph Smith, founder of the Mormons) who founded their own “Churches.”  He would literally have to hold that the Catholic Church fell into apostasy for centuries, by honoring and declaring as saints those he considers non-Catholic heretics, and that it is he who must come to “restore” the purity of the Gospel.  He even said that, if he could, he would “bring St. Thomas Aquinas back from Hell, put his skin on him, rip it off, and then pour vinegar on his wounds!”  Yes, R.I. actually said this while claiming to be Catholic (listen to part 4 of the audios below).

Part 1- Introduction and quick background on these radical schismatics [9 min audio.]

Part 2 - In depth refutation of their false arguments regarding the Council of Basel and the salvation dogma [50 min. audio]

Part 3 - Refutation of the Argument that Canonizations are not infallible by virtue of the teaching of Vatican I [20 min. audio]

Part 4 - Exposing the demonic and shocking statements of the schismatic RI – the source for many strains of "traditionalist" schism [16 min. audio]

REGARDING WHEN THE BAPTIZED CHILDREN OF HERETICS BECOME HERETICS – RELATING TO HIS HERETICAL ABJURATION AND THE DOGMA THAT ALL WHO DIE AS HERETICS ARE LOST

By Bro. Peter Dimond, O.S.B.

PART 1: The Schismatic R.I. hurls a new accusation against us and then refuses to defend his position in a debate; his position and abjuration are crushed by various teachings of the Church

-Introduction-

How the New Controversy Materialized

My first e-mail to R.I. challenging him to a debate

My second e-mail to R.I. challenging him to a debate and answering his first question

My third e-mail to R.I. challenging him to a debate and asking for a response to my question

My public letter to R.I. which reveals the teaching of the Council of Elvira, St. Francis De Sales, Pope Pius XI and more which crushes his position on when people become heretics and blows his schismatical abjuration away

Other brief points regarding the Schismatic R.I.

This Teaching on When People Become Heretics makes perfect sense

Part 2: A Brief Study demonstrating how this truth regarding when the baptized children of heretics become heretics is perfectly compatible with all the other dogmas on salvation

All who die without baptism are lost

Eugene IV defines that all who die as pagans, Jews, heretics and schismatics are lost

Regarding when and which people are heretics and schismatics

The Catholic Church teaches that infants baptized in heretical churches are Catholics

The Catholic Church teaches that infants baptized in heretical churches are also within the government of the Catholic Church

The Catholic Church teaches that infants baptized in heretical and schismatical churches are also subject to the Roman Pontiff

What is the “Catholic Faith” in its simplest components?

This truth is proven on the Mission Fields

Further demonstrating the utter stupidity of the position of R.I.

So, when do the baptized children of heretics become heretics?

Finally, this truth shows us something very important about the visibility of the Catholic Church in the times of the Great Apostasy